Fiscal Devolution and Northern Ireland: Capacity, Comparisons and Practical Constraints

Date: Jun 19, 2026

The House of Lords Economic Affairs Committee is examining whether greater fiscal autonomy can improve economic growth and public service delivery. This article considers what that debate means for Northern Ireland, comparing its fiscal framework with England and Scotland and assessing whether additional devolved powers could be exercised effectively and sustainably.

Introduction

The House of Lords Economic Affairs Committee has launched an inquiry into whether greater fiscal autonomy for local government in England can improve economic growth, strengthen democratic accountability and enhance public service delivery (the English Inquiry). While the English Inquiry is directed at local authorities in England, the issues it raises have wider constitutional and economic relevance across the United Kingdom.

The consensus is that the current fiscal powers of local authorities in England are insufficient and could be extended; the English Inquiry states that “the fiscal powers granted to local government remain minimal.” At its core, the English Inquiry is concerned with the relationship between fiscal powers and institutional capability. It asks not only whether powers should be devolved, but whether those receiving them have the capacity to exercise them effectively and sustainably. This provides a useful analytical framework for assessing Northern Ireland, whose fiscal settlement differs significantly from both English local authorities and other devolved administrations.

Two key considerations arise in this context. First, whether local government in Northern Ireland would, in principle, be better placed than central government in Westminster to manage increased fiscal powers. Second, whether, in practice, the Northern Ireland Executive could effectively exercise those powers to deliver improved economic and fiscal outcomes.

This article addresses these questions by examining the current fiscal position in Northern Ireland, comparing it with Scotland as a more developed model of devolved fiscal authority, and assessing the practical implications of any expansion of fiscal powers. In doing so, it draws on the findings of the Independent Fiscal Commission for Northern Ireland (the NI Fiscal Commission) from its May 2022 report, which provides the most detailed recent analysis of Northern Ireland’s fiscal capacity.

Consideration of the English Inquiry’s Questions

The English Inquiry is structured around several interrelated questions. These include:

  • what level of fiscal autonomy is desirable and sustainable;
  • whether devolved or local institutions have sufficient administrative and governance capacity;
  • whether fiscal devolution can drive economic growth and improve service delivery; and
  • what risks arise from transferring fiscal responsibility away from central government.

A unifying theme across these questions is the importance of fiscal alignment – that is, the degree to which spending responsibilities are matched by revenue-raising powers. The Committee’s concern is that without such alignment, local authorities in England may lack both the incentives and the tools necessary to manage public finances effectively.

A second key theme is institutional capability. Fiscal powers are not self-executing; they require administrative infrastructure, policy expertise and political stability in order to be used effectively. The English Inquiry therefore places considerable emphasis on whether local authorities in England have the capacity to take on additional responsibilities without compromising fiscal sustainability.

When applied to Northern Ireland, these questions highlight a critical distinction between theoretical capacity and practical reality. While Northern Ireland has a more developed system of devolved governance than English local authorities, its fiscal framework raises questions about whether additional powers could be implemented in a way that is both effective and sustainable.

Position in Northern Ireland

Northern Ireland occupies a distinctive position within the UK’s fiscal landscape. The NI Executive is responsible for a wide range of public services, including healthcare, education and infrastructure, giving it a level of expenditure reasonably comparable in scope to a devolved administration such as Scotland.

However, this breadth of responsibility is not matched by equivalent fiscal autonomy. Northern Ireland has only limited control over taxation and remains heavily reliant on the block grant allocated by the UK Government. As a result, there is a structural imbalance between the level of public expenditure managed by the NI Executive and the revenue it generates.

This imbalance lies at the heart of the NI Fiscal Commission’s analysis. The NI Fiscal Commission identified a persistent gap between expenditure demands, revenue capacity and economic performance, which places ongoing pressure on public finances. At paragraph 1.7.4 of its report, the NI Fiscal Commission states that, “At present, the NI Executive has only a small number of taxation powers at its disposal.” In this context, the absence of significant revenue-raising powers restricts the NI Executive’s ability to deploy fiscal policy as a tool for economic management or long-term strategic planning.

Although Northern Ireland possesses certain potential fiscal powers – notably the legislative framework for a devolved corporation tax rate—these have not been implemented. This reflects concerns about financial sustainability, including the potential cost of reducing corporation tax revenues, and the broader question of whether the NI Executive has the capacity to absorb such fiscal risks. Recommendation 2 of the NI Fiscal Commission’s report specifically addresses corporation tax and states, “[The Fiscal Commission] would encourage [the NI Executive] to demonstrate how it will ensure the sustainability of its finances following any reduction in corporation tax.”

The current framework in Northern Ireland therefore combines extensive spending responsibilities with limited fiscal autonomy, resulting in a model that prioritises stability and central oversight rather than flexibility or fiscal self-determination. At paragraph 1.6.20 of its report, the NI Fiscal Commission, “recognises the need to give due consideration to the implications of potential future political instability for any increased fiscal devolution.” This position is central to assessing how Northern Ireland would respond to further fiscal devolution.

Position in Scotland

Scotland represents a more developed model of fiscal devolution and provides a useful comparator for assessing Northern Ireland’s position.

The Scotland Acts of 2012 and 2016 significantly expanded the fiscal powers of the Scottish Parliament, granting it control over income tax rates and bands, devolved taxes such as land and landfill taxes, and enhanced borrowing powers. These reforms have created a closer alignment between revenue-raising powers and expenditure responsibilities than exists in Northern Ireland.

As a result, Scotland has been able to pursue a greater degree of policy divergence, tailoring its tax and spending decisions to reflect regional economic priorities. This has introduced both opportunities and challenges. On the one hand, it allows for more responsive and locally tailored policymaking. On the other hand, it increases exposure to economic volatility, particularly where tax revenues fluctuate in response to wider economic conditions.

Importantly, Scotland’s experience demonstrates that fiscal devolution is not a static or one-off process. It has evolved incrementally, supported by institutional development, political consensus and ongoing adjustments to the fiscal framework.

This gradual approach contrasts with Northern Ireland’s more constrained model and highlights the importance of institutional maturity and economic capacity in supporting expanded fiscal powers.

Comparison: Scotland, England and Northern Ireland

A comparative analysis of Scotland, English local authorities and Northern Ireland illustrates the different models of fiscal governance across the UK.

English local authorities operate within a relatively constrained fiscal framework. Their revenue-raising powers are limited, largely confined to council tax and business rates, and they remain dependent on central government funding. However, their responsibilities are broadly proportionate to those powers, resulting in a degree of alignment between revenue and expenditure.

Scotland, by contrast, has developed a more sophisticated fiscal model, with substantial control over both taxation and spending. This creates a clearer link between fiscal decisions and economic outcomes, enhancing accountability and policy flexibility.

Northern Ireland occupies an intermediate but structurally distinct position. It exercises control over significant public expenditure but has only limited revenue-raising powers. At paragraph 2.4.5 of the NI Fiscal Commission report, it is identified that, “the NI Executive is responsible for almost £9 in every £10 of identifiable spend across the region.” This creates a more pronounced imbalance than exists in either England or Scotland. The NI Fiscal Commission identified, at paragraph 2.6.1 of its report that, “amongst UK regions, Northern Ireland is among the lowest contributors of ‘total revenue’ per head.”

From the perspective of the English Inquiry, this comparison is significant. Northern Ireland may appear, at first glance, to be better placed than English local authorities to manage fiscal devolution due to its broader governmental role. However, the lack of alignment between revenue and expenditure suggests that its fiscal framework is less internally coherent.

In practical terms:

  • English local authorities operate within constraints, but with relative fiscal alignment;
  • Scotland operates with greater autonomy and greater alignment;
  • Northern Ireland operates with extensive responsibilities but limited control over revenue, resulting in structural imbalance.

This comparison suggests that Northern Ireland’s challenge is not simply a lack of powers, but the nature of its fiscal framework and its ability to support coherent fiscal policymaking.

Consideration of Practical Capacity

The central issue arising from both the English Inquiry and the NI Fiscal Commission’s analysis is whether Northern Ireland could realistically exercise increased fiscal powers if they were devolved.

The NI Fiscal Commission’s findings were clear that additional fiscal powers would not, in themselves, resolve Northern Ireland’s underlying fiscal challenges. The NI Fiscal Commission accepted that it did not consider, “full fiscal devolution, under which Northern Ireland would be responsible for funding all of its spending from its own revenues, as a realistic option.” Instead, such policies could expose the NI Executive to increased financial risk, particularly in the context of revenue volatility and economic uncertainty.

Economic Capacity and Revenue Volatility

Northern Ireland’s economy is relatively small and regionally concentrated. As a result, tax revenues may be more susceptible to fluctuations, particularly in sectors that are sensitive to wider economic conditions. Increased reliance on locally generated revenue would therefore expose the Executive to greater fiscal risk.

Institutional and Administrative Capability

The English Inquiry places significant emphasis on whether institutions can manage devolved fiscal powers effectively. In Northern Ireland, this raises questions about administrative capacity, policy development and fiscal oversight. Effective fiscal devolution requires sophisticated modelling, forecasting and decision-making capabilities, which must be developed and sustained over time.

Political Stability and Governance

Northern Ireland’s power-sharing arrangements have historically prioritised political stability and consensus-building. While this is essential to the functioning of devolved government, it may limit the speed and flexibility with which fiscal policy can be developed and implemented. Fiscal decisions often require decisive action, particularly in response to economic shocks, and such responsiveness may be constrained in a consensus-based system. The NI Fiscal Commission stated that, in the gathering of evidence for its report, a large number of people that it spoke to, “raised the issue of the political capacity of the NI Executive.”

Evidence from Existing Powers

The experience of devolved corporation tax provides a concrete example of the challenges involved. Although legislative authority exists, implementation has been delayed due to concerns about fiscal sustainability and broader economic impacts. This illustrates that the existence of fiscal powers does not of itself guarantee their practical utilisation.

Need for Complementary Reform

The NI Fiscal Commission emphasised that any expansion of fiscal powers must be accompanied by broader reforms aimed at improving productivity, economic performance and public sector efficiency. Without such reforms, additional fiscal autonomy is unlikely to generate meaningful improvements and may instead amplify existing fiscal pressures. In its summary of recommendations, the NI Fiscal Commission recommended that, “the NI Executive would have to ensure that appropriate structures and people were put in place before any devolution of tax powers.”

Taken together, these considerations suggest that the question is not simply whether Northern Ireland could receive additional fiscal powers, but whether it could integrate them into a coherent and sustainable fiscal framework.

Conclusion and Practical Recommendations

The English Inquiry highlights that fiscal devolution is fundamentally an issue of capability and coherence, rather than simply constitutional design.

Applied to Northern Ireland, the analysis suggests that while further fiscal devolution is theoretically possible, its practical benefits are uncertain in the absence of structural reform. The key challenge lies in the existing imbalance between expenditure responsibility and revenue control, which limits the NI Executive’s ability to use fiscal policy effectively.

In light of this, a number of practical recommendations emerge:

  • Focus on fiscal alignment: Any extension of fiscal powers should aim to reduce the imbalance between revenue and expenditure, rather than simply increasing autonomy in isolation.
  • Adopt a phased and targeted approach. Incremental devolution of specific, manageable powers is likely to be more effective than comprehensive reform.
  • Strengthen institutional capacity: Investment in analytical, administrative and policymaking capability will be essential to support effective fiscal governance.
  • Integrate fiscal policy with economic strategy: Fiscal devolution should form part of a broader programme focused on economic growth, productivity and public sector reform.
  • Ensure political consensus and stability: Sustainable fiscal policy requires long-term commitment and agreement across the NI Executive.

Ultimately, the experience of Scotland demonstrates that fiscal devolution can provide opportunities for greater accountability and economic responsiveness. However, the evidence from Northern Ireland suggests that these benefits are contingent on institutional readiness and economic capacity. The central question, therefore, is not whether Northern Ireland should receive greater fiscal powers, but whether it can realistically and effectively exercise them.

On the current evidence, any move towards increased fiscal autonomy would need to be carefully structured and supported by wider reform to ensure that it delivers sustainable and positive outcomes.

Editorial prepared by Andrew McClurg, Associate, Banking and Finance, Mills Selig

Cover Photo by atelierbyvineeth on Unsplash

Andrew McClurg, Associate, Banking & Finance
Andrew is a key member of Mills Selig’s Banking & Finance Team – regularly advising on a wide range of banking and finance matters, including corporate and commercial lending and real estate finance.

T: 028 9024 3878
E: 
Andrew.McClurg@MillsSelig.com
W: 
https://millsselig.com/team/Andrew-McClurg/


Based in Belfast, Mills Selig’s expert legal team provides clear, concise and solution-focused advice to businesses and individuals. Make Mills Selig #YourLegalTeam

🔗 Meet Mills Selig’s team of Solicitors

🔗 Learn about Mills Selig’s Commercial Legal Services

You may also like…

Mills Selig Increases Chambers UK Rankings for 2027

Mills Selig Increases Chambers UK Rankings for 2027

Mills Selig has increased its number of ranked practice areas in the Chambers UK Guide 2027, with recognition across 12 departments and 24 individual lawyer rankings, including a number of notable ranking improvements and new recognitions.

read more