This article was updated on 15 June 2026
Northern Ireland has seen a number of high‑profile trials in recent years that have generated significant media and social media attention.
Recent high-profile cases in Northern Ireland, including the prosecution arising from the murder of Natalie McNally, the ongoing Noah O’Donohoe inquest, and the current Donaldson proceedings, have generated significant media and social media attention.
While public interest is entirely understandable, these cases serve as an important reminder of the need to protect the integrity of the judicial process. Commenting on live proceedings, particularly online and without proper consideration, carries real legal risk.
In this article, we summarise the strict limits imposed by the law of contempt, limits which matter now more than ever in an age of instant and far-reaching commentary.
The administration of justice is safeguarded through several legal mechanisms, including the law of contempt. The following summary outlines the core principles relevant to journalists, media organisations, and members of the public. Its focus is on commentary relating to active cases, rather than behaviours such as breaches of court orders or misconduct in the courtroom.
The Contempt of Court Act 1981
The Act defines when conduct may amount to contempt and establishes the strict liability rule. A publication, whether spoken, written, broadcast, or online, may constitute contempt if it creates a substantial risk of seriously impeding or prejudicing active proceedings. The rule applies regardless of the publisher’s intention.
The strict liability rule covers communications addressed to the public at large or to any section of the public. Defences may include lack of reasonable awareness that proceedings were active, or publication of a fair and accurate contemporaneous report. Proceedings are usually deemed active from the moment of arrest.
The Act also prohibits seeking information about, or disclosing, jury deliberations.
Role of the Attorney General for Northern Ireland
The Attorney General plays a key role in enforcing contempt laws, particularly where a potentially prejudicial publication is involved. In 2024, the Attorney General issued a public reminder urging caution when commenting on active criminal cases, especially on social media.
Enforcement and Penalties
Although contempt is not a criminal offence in itself, courts retain the power to impose sanctions. Senior Courts may order imprisonment for up to two years and/or impose a fine. Other courts have more limited sentencing powers.
Dangers of Identifying Victims
Identifying victims, particularly in cases involving sexual offences, minors, or vulnerable individuals, is a serious concern. The identification of a victim of a sexual offence is itself an offence under the Sexual Offences (Amendment) Act 1992, as amended by the Justice (Sexual Offences and Trafficking Victims) Act (Northern Ireland) 2022.
Media organisations and online commentators must ensure that no information, even when pieced together from multiple sources, could lead to the identification of a protected victim.
Practical Guidance for Media and Online Commentators
Those reporting on or discussing ongoing Northern Ireland proceedings should exercise great care and avoid material that could create a substantial risk of prejudice. This includes:
- Expressing views on the guilt or innocence of a suspect
- Referring to the previous convictions of anyone involved
- Naming someone granted anonymity or who is under 18
- Identifying or providing details about the victim of a sexual offence
- Sharing evidence or facts that the judge has restricted from publication
For tailored advice on any of these issues, please contact the Media & Defamation Team at Mills Selig for specialist guidance.
Editorial prepared by Mark Thompson, Legal Director, Litigation and Media & Defamation at Mills Selig
Cover Photo by Tingey Injury Law Firm on Unsplash

Mark Thompson, Legal Director, Litigation
Mark Thompson is a Legal Director with Mills Selig’s Litigation team, he specialises in complex commercial disputes and media litigation.
As a highly experienced litigation lawyer, Mark advises businesses, senior executives and public bodies on high value and strategically significant matters.
T: 028 9044 5420
E: Mark.Thompson@MillsSelig.com
W: millsselig.com/team/mark-thompson/
Based in Belfast, Mills Selig’s expert legal team provides clear, commercially focused legal advice to businesses and individuals across Northern Ireland. From corporate transactions to commercial disputes, our solicitors deliver practical, solutions‑driven support. Make Mills Selig #YourLegalTeam
🔗 Meet Mills Selig’s team of solicitors
🔗 Explore Mills Selig’s commercial legal services



