Case analysis of Clerkenwell Lifestyle (UK) Ltd v HG Construction Ltd 12 Jun 2026 [2026] EWHC 1406 (TCC), KBD
Introduction
The Technology and Construction Court (TCC) recently considered whether correspondence agreeing an extension of time constituted a separate binding agreement or simply reflected the operation of the extension-of-time provisions within the parties’ contract. The case also serves as a reminder of the limited grounds on which an adjudicator’s decision can be challenged at enforcement stage.
Background
HG Construction Ltd (HG) was engaged under an amended JCT Design and Build Contract 2016 to design and construct a 153-room hotel and nine affordable apartments in Clerkenwell, London. The original completion dates were May 2023 for the residential works and June 2023 for the hotel. During 2022, HG notified delays arising from matters including a Covid outbreak, transport strikes, adverse weather, and material supply issues, and sought a 12-week extension of time. Following correspondence between the parties, the Employer’s Agent formally granted a 12-week extension under the contractual extension-of-time mechanism, relying on adverse weather and strike action.
Adjudication
The project was significantly delayed, with the hotel completing in October 2024 and the residential units in February 2025. Clerkenwell sought approximately £1.1 million in liquidated damages and referred the dispute to adjudication. HG argued it was entitled to further extensions of time arising from the delays previously identified. Although the adjudicator awarded some additional time, he largely found in favour of Clerkenwell and ordered HG to pay around £956,000 in liquidated damages.
A key aspect of the adjudicator’s decision was that he did not treat the previously extended completion dates as an agreed contractual baseline for assessing future extensions. Instead, he determined HG’s entitlement by reference to the original contractual completion dates and the delays established in the adjudication.
What did the Court say?
HG challenged the decision in the TCC, arguing that the earlier email correspondence amounted to a separate binding agreement which fixed revised completion dates that should have been used as the starting point for further extension-of-time assessments.
The Court rejected that argument. Viewed objectively and in the context of the contract as a whole, the correspondence was simply part of the contractual extension-of-time process rather than a standalone agreement varying the parties’ rights. The Court noted that the formal extension-of-time notification issued by the Employer’s Agent, together with the parties’ subsequent conduct, supported that conclusion. The Court was also critical of the fact that HG had not advanced this argument during the adjudication, despite having had the opportunity to do so.
Although the decision is not binding on the courts of Northern Ireland, it may be persuasive and is relevant to issues commonly arising on local construction projects, particularly where parties discuss extensions of time or changes to contractual rights through informal correspondence.
Key Takeaway and Conclusion
The decision highlights that not every agreement reached during a project amounts to a contractual variation. Parties wishing to revise completion dates or alter contractual rights should do so clearly and expressly. The case also emphasises that objective intention, subsequent conduct, and the authority of the person agreeing any variation are all important considerations. Finally, parties should raise all material contractual arguments during adjudication, as it is difficult to resist enforcement by relying on substantially different arguments later.
Editorial by Conor Mulligan, Associate Solicitor, Construction @ Mills Selig with additional research by Drew O’Hanlon, Trainee Solicitor, Mills Selig
For further information on all of the above, do not hesitate to contact the Construction Team at Mills Selig

Conor Mulligan, Associate Solicitor, Construction @ Mills Selig
Conor specialises in both contentious and non-contentious work in Mills Selig’s Construction department. He has been involved in mediating, litigating and adjudicating high-value construction, engineering and procurement disputes.
He provides advice on drafting and negotiating construction documents to a wide range of clients including developers, professional consultants, contractors and sub-contractors.
T: 028 9044 5404
E: Conor.Mulligan@MillsSelig.com
W: https://millsselig.com/team/conor-mulligan/
Based in Belfast, Mills Selig’s expert legal team provides clear, concise and solution-focused advice to businesses and individuals. Make Mills Selig #YourLegalTeam



