The Northern Ireland Executive’s decision to proceed with a long-awaited upgrade to the A5 has been quashed following a judicial review challenge by an interest group known as the Alternative A5 Alliance.
Delivering his judgment yesterday, Mr Justice McAlinden held that the decision to approve the scheme was irrational and should be set aside. His decision was based primarily on the lack of evidence regarding the scheme’s impact on Northern Ireland’s ability to meet statutory net zero targets.
The project has been contentious both from the perspective of the potential environmental impact and due to the significant number of deaths which have occurred on the existing road over the past few decades.
The judgment leaves the Executive’s plans in limbo and local residents and road users questioning whether (and in what form) the scheme will be revived. It is of course possible that the Department will appeal the decision. On any view, the scheme is likely to suffer further significant delay.
In the meantime, the Executive has already compulsorily acquired land which previously belonged to residents and farmers of the area surrounding the route. It seems most unlikely that any steps will be taken to unravel the vesting process (whereby the State can take ownership of land regardless of whether the landowner wishes to sell). Landowners who were subject to Vesting Orders in late 2024 are entitled to claim compensation and we are advising clients in relation to the process involved.
The litigation team at Mills Selig is experienced in handling both applications to the Lands Tribunal and judicial review matters with a commercial slant.
Editorial prepared by Kirsten Magee, Partner, Litigation @ Mills Selig

Kirsten Magee, Partner, Litigation
Kirsten is a highly skilled and experienced commercial litigator with a background in advising both private and public sector clients on a wide range of complex, high-value disputes.
T: 028 9024 3878
E: Kirsten.Magee@MillsSelig.com
W: https://millsselig.com/team/kirsten-magee/
Based in Belfast, Mills Selig’s expert legal team provide clear, concise and solution-focused advice to businesses and individuals. Make Mills Selig #YourLegalTeam



